Skip to main content
Before You Sign

Who Is the “Signed By” – Notary vs. Witness vs. Commissioner: NY Titles Explained

By November 20, 2026November 21st, 2026No Comments

Turn to the last page of almost any important document and you will find a small theater of signatures. There is your signature, of course. There may be a line for a witness. And there is a block of formal-looking text ending with “Signed and sealed by,” followed by a name, a title, and a commission expiration date. Most clients sign the first line, ignore the rest, and hope for the best.

Then the document comes back. The bank says the deed “wasn’t notarized right.” The county clerk says the acknowledgment was “taken before an unauthorized officer.” Someone asks whether the person who signed the block was “a notary or a commissioner,” and whether it matters.

It matters. New York law recognizes a small set of people who can put their official signature on your document, and each performs a different job with a different legal effect. This post explains the titles you will actually see on New York paperwork – what each one is, what each one signs, and how to tell a proper signature block from a decorative one.

First, the Organizing Idea: Three Kinds of “Signed By”

Every signature block on a New York document is doing one of three things:

  1. The signer (the “principal”) attests to the content. Your signature says, “This is what I agreed to.” In notarial language, you are the principal – the person whose signature is reflected on the record.

  2. The witness attests to the event. A witness signature says, “I saw this person sign, and they appeared to do it voluntarily.” The witness certifies nothing official about the signer’s identity or the document’s content. They are lending their eyes.

  3. The notarial officer attests to identity and the act. When a notary public (or one of the other authorized officers) signs, that signature is an official act of the State of New York. The officer certifies that the signer appeared, was identified, and signed willingly – and the seal makes that certification something courts, banks, and county clerks must accept as evidence.

That third category is where the titles get confusing, because New York authorizes more than one kind of officer, and one of them – the commissioner of deeds – is a genuine office you can still encounter, not a myth.

The Notary Public: The Title You Will See Almost Every Time

A notary public in New York is a public officer appointed by the Secretary of State under the Notaries Public Law. The appointment is called a commission. That single word trips up clients constantly. There is no “commission” that outranks a notary’s commission; the commission is simply the license itself, valid for four years, after which the notary must renew.

Executive Law Section 135 spells out what a qualified notary is empowered to do statewide: administer oaths and affirmations, take affidavits and depositions, and “receive and certify acknowledgments or proof of deeds, mortgages and powers of attorney and other instruments in writing.” When a notary signs your document, that is the authority standing behind the signature. Know, then, what a notarization actually is.

An acknowledgment is the act behind most “Signed By” blocks. When you have a deed, a power of attorney, or a contract notarized, you are usually having it acknowledged: you appear before the officer, confirm it is your signature, and confirm you signed willingly. Nothing is sworn. The notary certifies the how and who of your signature, not the what of the document.

A sworn statement (an oath or affirmation) is a different act. There, the notary administers an oath and you sign under penalty of perjury that the contents are true. Affidavits get this treatment; deeds generally do not.

If a notary ever tells you they are “notarizing the contents” of your contract, that is a red flag, not a credential. New York notaries do not certify that a document is legal, valid, or wise. They certify the signing.

Reading the Notarial Certificate Line by Line

New York’s Real Property Law sets the requirements for an acknowledgment certificate (Section 303, “Requisites of acknowledgments”), and the customary form for documents that will be recorded reads roughly like this:

State of New York ) County of ________ ) ss: On ____, before me, the subscriber, personally appeared ____, known to me or proved to me on the basis of satisfactory evidence to be the individual whose name is subscribed to the within instrument… (Signature and title of officer) Commission expires: ____

Each line is load-bearing. “Personally appeared” is the presence requirement. “Known to me or proved to me” is the identification standard – either the notary genuinely knows you, or you present identification the notary accepts. The signature-and-title line ties the act to a specific commissioned officer, and the commission number and expiration date let anyone verify the officer held office on the date claimed. A missing commission number is one of the quiet defects that can get a recorded document challenged.

When the Notarization Happens Remotely

As a New York remote online notary, I perform this same act over secure audio-video. Executive Law Article 13-A (Section 135-c) authorizes it with strict conditions: the notary must be physically inside New York at the moment of the act, regardless of where the signer is; identity is confirmed through approved technology-based standards; and the audio-video recording of the session must be kept for at least ten years. The certificate must state that the signer “appeared through use of communication technology” instead of “personally appeared.”

So if you ask whether a remote notarization is “less official,” the answer is no. The officer, the act, and the certification are identical. Only the appearance changes.

The Witness: Eyes, Not Authority

The line on your document that says “Witness:” is a completely different animal, and no official appointment is required for it.

A witness is a private individual who observed the signing. New York requires witnesses for a handful of important documents, and the requirements are specific:

  • Powers of attorney. Any New York financial power of attorney signed on or after June 13, 2021 must be signed in the presence of two witnesses (General Obligations Law Section 5-1502). Here is the overlap that surprises people: the notary taking the acknowledgment may also serve as one of the two witnesses. One commissioned officer can legitimately fill two lines on the signature page – but the second witness line must still be a real, separate person.
  • Health care proxies. Two adult witnesses under Public Health Law Article 29-C (Section 2981). No notary is required at all – and your appointed health care agent cannot be one of the witnesses.
  • Wills. Two subscribing witnesses under the Estates, Powers and Trusts Law (Section 3-2.1). A notary is never required to make a will valid; notarization appears only on the self-proving affidavit, a convenience that can spare your witnesses a court appearance later.
  • Lifetime trusts. Under EPTL 7-1.17, a trust executed in New York must either be acknowledged like a deed (notarial act) or signed before two witnesses. Which path your document took is written into its own execution clause.
  • Transfer-on-death deeds. New York’s TOD deed statute (Real Property Law Section 424, effective 2024) requires two witnesses and a notarial acknowledgment and recording before the owner’s death – a document that uses both kinds of signatures at once.

The critical practical rule: a witness attests that they saw you sign; a notary certifies that you were identified and acted willingly. Some documents need one, some need both. And if a document says “in the presence of two witnesses,” remote notarization cannot substitute for those witnesses – a real person at the table is doing a job technology does not replace.

The Commissioner: The Old Title That Is Still Real

This one generates the most head-scratching questions, usually from clients with older deeds or family members in New York City.

Commissioner of Deeds: A Genuine Office

A commissioner of deeds is a real New York notarial officer. The office descends from English law, where commissioners for deeds were appointed to take acknowledgments of documents executed far from home. New York kept the office, and current statutes still name it.

Real Property Law Section 298, which lists who may take the acknowledgment of a deed within New York, includes judges and clerks of courts of record, the mayor or recorder of a city, surrogates, county clerks and other recording officers – and, specifically, “a commissioner of deeds outside of the city of New York, or a commissioner of deeds of the city of New York within the five counties comprising the city of New York.”

In New York City, the office still exists in practice. The City Clerk’s office describes a commissioner of deeds as “a public officer similar to a Notary Public who may administer oaths and take acknowledgements or proofs of deeds and other documents in any part of the City of New York.”

There is a second, narrower kind: commissioners of deeds appointed under New York law specifically to take acknowledgments and proofs outside the state. Real Property Law Sections 299 and 301 – the statutes governing documents signed out-of-state or abroad – list these commissioners alongside judges, mayors, consular officials, and notaries public as proper officers before whom a New York deed’s acknowledgment may be taken. If your grandmother signed her New York deed in Florida in 1987, the Florida notary was fine; and so was any commissioner of deeds New York itself had appointed for out-of-state work.

“Commission” Confusion: The Lookalikes

Because the notary’s license is itself called a commission, the word “commissioner” floats around documents in misleading ways:

  • “Commission expires” under a notary’s signature does not refer to a commissioner. It is the expiration date of the notary’s own appointment.
  • The county clerk files the commission. When a notary is appointed, the Secretary of State forwards the commission to the county clerk, where the notary takes the oath of office and files a signature specimen. Clients sometimes assume the county clerk’s records are a second layer of approval for their document. They are not – they are the notary’s registration paperwork.
  • “Signing agent” or “loan signing agent” is not a title at all. In New York there is one notarial commission and no higher credential, exam, or endorsement attached to closings – and one fee schedule behind it: two dollars per notarial act in person, or twenty-five for an electronic/remote act (Executive Law Section 136). A signing agent is simply a notary experienced with mortgage documents. Beware anyone who charges more because they claim to be “commissioned” beyond an ordinary notary – either they are describing the ordinary commission, or they are describing a commissioner of deeds, which is a separate office with its own appointment.

Holding Out a Title You Do Not Have

The state takes these title lines seriously enough to make false ones a crime. Executive Law Section 135-a makes it a misdemeanor for any person to assume, use, or advertise the title of notary public or commissioner of deeds – or equivalent terms in any language – without having first been appointed to that office. The words under a signature block are not decoration: they assert official authority, backed by a penal statute.

What the Law Makes Each Signature Prove

Why should a county clerk or a bank care what the title line says? Because New York attaches specific evidentiary weight to official signatures – and a 2024 amendment (Senate Bill S2271, Chapter 502 of the Laws of 2024) made the rules for out-of-state documents much cleaner.

Under RPL Section 299 as amended:

  • The signature and title of a notarial officer of another state are prima facie evidence that the signature is genuine and the person holds the claimed title. A clerk may ask, but the presumption favors your document.
  • For the most common officers – a judge, a notary public of another state, or a commissioner of deeds appointed under New York law to act outside the state – the signature and title conclusively establish the officer’s authority to take the acknowledgment.
  • New York eliminated the old “certificate of conformity,” a separate extra document once required to confirm that an out-of-state notary complied with their own state’s laws. A proper out-of-state acknowledgment is now treated as equivalent to a New York one.

For documents acknowledged in foreign countries, RPL Section 301 lists the proper officers (U.S. ambassadors and consuls, foreign judges and notaries, and New York-appointed commissioners of deeds), and RPL Section 311 governs their authentication. This is also where an apostille enters the picture: when a document will be used abroad, the New York Secretary of State certifies the notary’s commission so the foreign authority will accept it. An apostille authenticates the officer; it is not itself a notarization.

Within New York, the officer who takes an acknowledgment must sign a certificate stating “all the matters required to be done, known, or proved” (RPL Section 306) – which is why a proper block recites appearance, identification, and the officer’s signature and title, and why an incomplete one invites rejection.

The Real-World Consequences of the Wrong “Signed By”

Here is what goes wrong when the wrong kind of signature ends up in the wrong line:

  1. A deed rejected at the counter. A deed acknowledged before an officer whose commission had expired, or with no commission number on the certificate, will not record cleanly. Recording is what protects ownership; a deed stuck at the county clerk is a closing stuck in neutral.
  2. A power of attorney with zero real witnesses. Two witnesses are required for post-2021 POAs. Signers sometimes assume the notary covers the whole page. Notary-plus-one-witness is legal; notary alone is defective, and banks spot it.
  3. A “witnessed only” document sent to be recorded. A witness line proves eyes were present, not identity. A deed or mortgage needing an acknowledgment cannot be fixed with two neighbors’ signatures; it needs re-execution or re-acknowledgment before an authorized officer.
  4. An old family deed that looks wrong but is perfectly fine. Deeds acknowledged before “Commissioners of Deeds” – including New York City ones – routinely surface in title searches and are valid. Knowing the office exists saves a needless scare and a needless re-recording fee.
  5. A remote notarization with no mention of technology. If the certificate claims personal appearance for an act actually done by video, without the required “appeared through use of communication technology” language, the record can be challenged. The form has to match the method.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a commissioner of deeds higher than a notary public? Neither. They are different offices, not different ranks. For everyday New York documents, the notary public is the officer you will use – and remote notarization is performed only by registered notaries public.

Do I need a notary if my document already has witnesses? It depends on the document. Wills and health care proxies need witnesses and no notary. Deeds need the notarial act. Powers of attorney, as of 2021, need both, with the notary allowed to be one of the witnesses. The signature block on the document itself tells you which world you are in; when it does not, ask the person preparing the document, not the officer, whose job stops at the signing.

Can the same person be my witness and my notary? Only partially. For a POA the notary may be one of the two witnesses, but never both. For a health care proxy, the appointed agent can never serve as a witness. And a notary who is a party to the document, or who has a financial or beneficial interest in it, cannot notarize it at all – New York courts have treated such acknowledgments as nullities.

My grandfather’s 1968 deed says “Commissioner of Deeds.” Is it invalid? No. The office is named in New York’s Real Property Law for acknowledgments taken both inside and outside the state. An old certificate naming that title is a sign of a proper officer, not an error.

Does a remote notarization produce a different kind of signature block? A nearly identical one. The certificate states the appearance was through communication technology, and the notary applies a registered electronic signature that is unique to them and detects alteration. Recording officers accept a properly certified paper copy of an electronic record.

What is an apostille, and is it the same as notarizing? No. A notary certifies your signature; an apostille, issued through the Secretary of State, certifies the notary’s authority so a foreign government will accept the document. It is a second step after notarization, not a substitute.

How to Make Sure the Right People Sign

  1. Read the signature block before you sign it. Count the lines. The document is telling you who it needs.
  2. Know which act you are getting – an acknowledgment (identity and willingness) or a sworn statement (contents under oath).
  3. Verify the officer. A New York notary’s commission can be confirmed through the Department of State and the county clerk where they filed. If a title line claims “Commissioner of Deeds,” make sure it reflects a real appointment, not a marketing flourish.
  4. Line up witnesses separately. A notary is not automatically also your witness.

Final Thoughts

The last page of a document is the part institutions actually read. Your signature proves you agreed; a witness’s signature proves someone was watching; a notary’s or commissioner’s signature proves the State vouches for the identity behind the ink. New York draws clear lines between these roles – and honors every one of them, including the old ones, when the title is true.

When you book a signing, you are hiring an officer of the state. Ask what act is being performed, check that the title line matches the person, and make sure the block on the page matches the law for your document type. That is the whole trick of the “Signed By” line – and now you know it better than most of the people who sign on it.


Disclaimer: This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Document execution requirements vary by document type and circumstance; consult a licensed New York attorney about your specific situation.

elizabeth

Hi, I’m Liz — your friendly New York Remote Online Notary, and I’m here to make document notarization easy, legal, and stress-free! I’m a licensed NY commissioner and a Remote Online Notary, trained in all the latest notary laws, TPUA procedures, and security protocols.